Listen to this note in this podcast.
The central idea, in a few lines
The planet has a limited capacity to reorganise the carbon we disperse. When the rate at which we release it exceeds that capacity, the system becomes unbalanced. That is, in physical terms, climate change. And sustainability, from that same logic, is simply about realigning those two speeds.
It is not ideology. It is physics.
First, the basics: everything tends towards disorder
There is a physical law that describes something we all intuit without having studied it: without a continuous input of energy, organisation degrades. Materials wear out. Structures deteriorate. Organisms age.
This is called entropy, and the Second Law of Thermodynamics formalises it: in closed systems, entropy tends to increase. In other words, maintaining complex structures requires energy available continuously.
The Earth, however, is not a closed system. It receives energy from the Sun constantly, and that changes everything. (Schrödinger, 1944; Prigogine, 1977)
Life is the process that harnesses that energy to create order
The solar energy that reaches the planet is low-entropy energy: concentrated, useful, capable of doing work. Living beings capture it before it degrades into diffuse heat.
The central mechanism is photosynthesis:
CO₂ + H₂O + solar energy → biomass + O₂
Through this process, carbon transitions from a dispersed form —atmospheric CO₂— to complex structures: plant tissues, soil organic matter, biomolecules. In physical terms, life creates local organisation while exporting entropy to the environment. It does not violate the laws of physics: it pays for them with solar energy. (Schrödinger, 1944; Kleidon, 2010)
It is an important distinction: life does not cancel entropy. It actively manages it, as long as the flow of solar energy is not interrupted.
Carbon as a thermometer of the system's state
Carbon can be found at different levels of organisation. At one end, atmospheric CO₂: simple, dispersed molecules. At the other, fossil fuels: highly concentrated carbon, accumulated over millions of years. In the middle, living biomass and organic soils, where carbon is integrated into active biological networks.
The carbon cycle describes the movement between these states. Photosynthesis organises carbon. Respiration and decomposition redistribute it. Combustion disperses it rapidly.
The distribution of carbon in the Earth system, at any moment, reflects the dynamic balance between these processes. (NASA, 2022; IPCC, 2021)
What changed in the last two centuries
For thousands of years, this cycle remained in dynamic equilibrium. The biosphere reorganised carbon at a rate comparable to that at which natural processes released it.
Human activity introduced a change of scale: we began to release fossil carbon —accumulated over millions of years— in decades.
The concentration of atmospheric CO₂ rose from approximately280 ppmbefore the Industrial Revolution to over 420 ppm currently(IPCC, 2021). In the paleoclimatic records of the last 800,000 years, changes of that magnitude occurred over thousands of years. Today they occur in decades. (Global Carbon Project, 2023; IPCC, 2021)
The key data is not just how much carbon we release. It is the speed at which we do it.
Why that matters: the logic of rates
When a fossil fuel is burned, carbon moves from an organised chemical structure to dispersed CO₂ molecules in the atmosphere. Energy concentrated over millions of years is released in minutes.
The biosphere continues to reorganise carbon through photosynthesis, but the rate of dispersion currently exceeds its absorption capacity.
This can be expressed directly:
dC_atm/dt = R_disp − R_reorg
whereR_dispis the rate of carbon dispersion andR_reorgis the rate of reorganisation through photosynthesis and natural sinks.
The current approximate values are:
• R_disp ≈ 11 GtC per year(total human emissions)
• R_reorg ≈ 6–7 GtC per year(absorption by oceans and biosphere)
The difference—between 4 and 5 GtC annually—remains in the atmosphere.It is not a metaphor: it is the direct physical mechanism of the problem. (Global Carbon Project, 2023; IPCC, 2021)
How that imbalance becomes climate change
CO₂ is a greenhouse gas: it reduces the Earth's ability to release energy into space. As its concentration increases, more energy enters than leaves.
The global average temperature has increased by approximately1.1 °Csince the period 1850–1900(IPCC, 2021). A warmer atmosphere holds more water vapour, which intensifies the hydrological cycle and increases the frequency and intensity of extreme events.(IPCC, 2021; IPCC, 2022)
Climate change, in this sense, is the observable manifestation of the imbalance in the carbon cycle. It is not a separate problem: it is the same equation viewed from its consequences.
The biosphere has a physical ceiling, not just a political one.
The capacity for carbon reorganisation mainly depends on photosynthesis, which operates with the solar energy available at the Earth's surface.
The average solar flux absorbed by the Earth is on the order of 240 W/m². The power that the biosphere effectively converts into biomass is only 1 to 2 W/m² (Kleidon, 2010). The difference gives an idea of how many conversion steps and inefficiencies mediate between solar flux and the actual capacity for biological reorganisation.
This capacity is constrained by concrete conditions: available photosynthetic surface, water, nutrients, temperature, ecological dynamics. The biosphere can adapt within certain ranges, but it cannot indefinitely compensate for any rate of dispersion. There is a physical limit, not just a matter of political will or international agreements. (IPCC, 2022)
A definition of sustainability that does not require ideology
From this perspective, sustainability can be precisely defined:
It is the dynamic balance between the rate of carbon dispersion and the rate of reorganisation through biological processes.
When both rates are aligned, the atmospheric concentration of carbon stabilises. This does not imply that the system is static or that we need to return to a pre-industrial state. It implies that the rate at which we disperse concentrated resources does not exceed the rate at which biological processes can reconstitute them.
It is a condition of rhythm, not of quantity. (Georgescu-Roegen, 1971; Daly, 1996)
What does this imply for energy
The use of fossil fuels introduces carbon from geological reserves into the active cycle of the Earth system. It increases R_disp without modifying R_reorg. The equation worsens.
Sources based on current energy flows — photovoltaic solar, thermal solar, wind, hydro, sustainable biomass — do not add fossil carbon to the cycle. They use the energy that is already circulating in the Earth system, rather than mobilising reserves that took millions of years to form.
The energy transition, from this framework, is not just a climate policy. It is the adjustment of R_disp to make it comparable to R_reorg again. (IPCC, 2022)
In summary
Life organises carbon using solar energy. Fossil combustion rapidly disperses carbon that took millions of years to accumulate. This mismatch between rates modifies the planet's energy balance and manifests in climate change.
Sustainability, in physical terms, consists of realigning those speeds: operating within the continuous flow of available energy, rather than relying on the stock accumulated over geological eras.
In simple terms: not living off the capital accumulated over millions of years, but from the income that arrives each day.
Entropy is not an inevitable destiny. But ignoring the times of reorganisation of the planet is not a viable strategy.
References
Schrödinger, E. (1944). What is Life? Cambridge University Press.
Prigogine, I. (1977). Time, Structure and Fluctuations. Nobel Lecture, Stockholm.
Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1971). The Entropy Law and the Economic Process. Harvard University Press.
Daly, H. E. (1996). Beyond Growth: The Economics of Sustainable Development. Beacon Press.
Kleidon, A. (2010). A basic introduction to the thermodynamics of the Earth system far from equilibrium. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 365(1545), 1303–1315.
IPCC (2021). Sixth Assessment Report, Working Group I: The Physical Science Basis. Cambridge University Press.
IPCC (2022). Sixth Assessment Report, Working Group II: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Cambridge University Press.
Global Carbon Project (2023). Global Carbon Budget 2023. Earth System Science Data.
NASA (2022). The Carbon Cycle. NASA Earth Observatory.